The recent decision of Turkish authorities to block social media sites sparked outrage and conversation amongst both locals and the global world. Amiss upcoming elections, the nation’s government announced a ban on sites such as Twitter, Facebook and YouTube when a picture of a Turkish prosecutor held at gunpoint after being taken hostage began circulating across multiple Internet platforms.

The closing of 166 other websites alongside these primary social media sites provoked significant questions about ideas of censorship and the freedom of speech. As Westerners looking at the situation from an outside perspective, our immediate thoughts may have included “how could they do that?” and “the government is oppressive” amongst other reactions of shock and horror. These thoughts are all valid, as we believe that the United States government could never manage to shut down all major social media sites without a public outcry regarding basic democratic rights.

However, it is important to look at the internal workings of Turkey in order to understand the government’s ability to control media. This ability is a result of a new Internet law that “allows Turkey’s telecommunications authority to block any website without seeking a court ruling first and without giving the website an opportunity first to remove the offending content.”

Screen Shot 2015-04-16 at 1.56.23 PM

Photo courtesy of Flickr User opensource.com 

Social media, a much more recent addition to Turkish society, has been used as a main tool for communication and information since its introduction. Its popularity in Turkey grew as a result of emerging criticisms of the mainstream media as pro-government and censored. However, this incident highlights the government’s ability to control this new form of media as well.

European Parliament President Martin Schulz commented on the actions as “definitely inappropriate”, suggesting that rather than shut down entire sites until certain content is removed, “there is always the option to delete the picture, rather than closing the whole system.” I agree with Schulz’ concerns regarding ideas about freedom of speech, freedom of the press and the country’s media situation. If the government holds the ability to control each and every one of these, is there really any freedom? I believe the biggest problem is the new law that Turkish authorities have enforced, as the inability for social media companies to publish information without a court order seems quite absurd. The law also encourages companies to remain silent and comply with the government because of their fear of being shut down. These fears, although rational, create a timid society where citizens lack basic freedoms associated with democracy.

The timing of this censorship also raises significant questions, and I wonder how the discussion surrounding it would be different if this wasn’t the second time the government intervened on social media right before elections. Regardless, the move reveals a major shift towards censorship that is extremely worrisome, especially for a country eager to join the EU.

Screen Shot 2015-04-16 at 2.00.33 PM

Photo taken as a screenshot from Youtube User RT. 

Efe Kerem Sozeri, a Turkish researcher and opposition activist, reported that in 2014 more than 70 Twitter accounts and 2000 tweets were blocked in Turkey. “This is where the freedom of speech in Turkey is. Any critical remark, even if it’s based on real facts, you are not able to say that, because the interpretation of the law is given to those courts who are under the strong influence of the justice ministry”, he said.

For an American citizen like myself, it is difficult to grasp the idea that I would legally not be able to share my unfiltered opinions via social media platforms or pictures that the Turkish government did not agree with. Basic democratic ideals must shift as our society shifts and adapts to technological innovations, and Turkey’s government is clearly lagging behind.

Feature Image Courtesy of Flickr User opensource.com


One thought on “No Tweeting in Turkey Allowed

  1. I agree with you and Schulz that it would make more sense to just delete the picture rather than shut down all of social media for Turkey. I also agree that it seems absurd that the government can shut down something like that without a court warrant or order; this gives the government unbelievable control in freedom of press and freedom of speech. I understand why they shut down social media outlets given the situation, but that still doesn’t give them a right to do it without some sort of system of checks and balances. (From my understanding and research they eventually got a court order, but only after they had already put the ban into effect.) I am curious as to what other laws they have passed and will pass if they were able to pass this law so easily.

    I too, Devan, am worried about Turkey trying to join the EU with a system like this in place. The rest of Europe certainly would not agree with the freedom of speech that this new law in Turkey prohibits. I was surprised when reading a Time Magazine article (http://time.com/32864/turkey-bans-twitter/) about the event to hear the words of the Turkish Prime Minister stating the following, “I don’t care what the international community says. Everyone will witness the power of the Turkish Republic.” Clearly, Turkey is not worried about what the rest of the EU will think or anyone with the upcoming elections. Interestingly enough, in the aftermath, the Turkish President has stated that he was against the bans. I guess we will never know exactly the whole truth…

    I feel like this would never be possible in the United States because there are a higher number of people who use social media to shut out and because there would be a huge backlash. Things may even spread faster through social media in the U.S. than a lot of other places in the world. The Washington Post was the publication who leaked the video that got YouTube banned in Turkey (http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2014/03/28/heres-the-video-that-got-youtube-banned-in-turkey/?wpisrc=nl_headlines). I am curious to see if this happens anywhere else in the world as social media spreads to more and more places and becomes more relevant in everyday life.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s